Reading the labels

Surplus, Reclaimed or Recycled Carpet Tiles: What Each Label Actually Means

Reclaimed carpet tiles have been laid, lifted and cleaned for another floor. Surplus tiles were never laid at all. Recycled tiles are new tiles made partly from recovered material. The three labels get used as if they meant the same thing, but they describe different products, at different prices, with different condition and different carbon arguments behind them. If you are comparing listings across sites, the first question to settle is which of the three you are actually looking at.

Three labels, side by side
QuestionSurplusReclaimedRecycled
Laid before?NeverYes — lifted from a floorNo — a new tile
Where it comes fromOver-orders, spares, end-of-line stockFloors being stripped outA manufacturer's current range
ConditionNew, with a storage historyWorn to the degree it was usedNew
WarrantyUsually stays with the first buyerBelonged to the first installationYours, on the maker's terms
Priced againstThe same range bought newIts wear and the work of recovering itThe manufacturer's own price list
Carbon basisNo new tile made for that areaNo new tile made, less the recovery workLess virgin material in a new tile

Surplus: new stock that was never fitted

Surplus is manufactured tile that reached a job, or a warehouse, and was never put down. Nobody has walked on it. What it has instead is a history: how long it has been stored, where, and how many times it has been moved. That is what decides its condition, and it is why a surplus listing describes boxes, batch codes and storage rather than wear.

Search for second hand carpet tiles UK and surplus will appear alongside everything else, which is where buyers get confused. Surplus is not second-hand in the ordinary sense, because there was no first use. It is the only stock Carpet Unboxed lists, and the guide to what "boxed and unused" means covers what that label does and does not promise.

Reclaimed and refurbished: lifted, cleaned, resold

Reclaimed tile has had a working life. It was laid on a floor, the floor was stripped out — at the end of a lease, or in a refit — and the tiles were lifted rather than thrown away. Usable ones are sorted from the rest, cleaned and sold on. Refurbished is the word some sellers use once that work has been done; it tells you something happened to the tiles, but not what, so it is always worth asking.

The questions that matter for reclaimed stock are different from those for surplus. How much wear is left in the pile, and is it even across the lot or concentrated in tiles that came from a corridor? What was the floor fixed with, and how much of it is still on the backing? The guide to fixing second-hand tiles covers why old adhesive matters when the tiles go down again. And were they all lifted from one floor, or gathered from several, which tells you how likely they are to match?

Carpet Unboxed grew out of Welltek's carpet-tile reclaim work, so we would not describe reclaim as second best. It is a different product, and it suits jobs where a sound, cleaned tile at the right price matters more than one that has never been walked on.

Recycled: new tiles made with recovered material

Recycled carpet tiles are not reused tiles at all. They are new tiles from a manufacturer's range, made with a proportion of recovered material in place of new raw material. You buy them new, from the maker or a distributor, ordered to the quantity and batch the job needs.

The figure to look for is the recycled content of the specific product, which the manufacturer states. Two things are easy to confuse with it. A range described as recyclable tells you what can happen to the tile at the end of its life, not what is in it now. And a recycled-content figure quoted for a whole range may not apply to every product within it, so check it against the product you are actually specifying.

Price per square metre compared

We do not publish prices for reclaimed or recycled tile, and we are not going to guess at typical rates: they vary with the seller, the range and the quantity. What we can say is how each one is priced, which is what lets you compare listings fairly.

Surplus is priced against what the same range costs new, less whatever makes the lot less useful than a new delivery: mixed batches, part boxes, a colour few floors can take. Prices are shown per square metre on the listing. As this was written, a lot of Milliken Formworks 3.0 on our feed was listed at £18.00 per m² — one listing, not a guide to the market.

Reclaimed is priced on the condition of the tiles and the work of recovering them: lifting, sorting, cleaning and moving. Ask whether the price covers tiles that turn out to be unusable, and how many the seller expects there to be.

Recycled tile is a new product, priced by its manufacturer like any other range. Its recycled content is a specification, not a discount.

To compare any two of them, put them on the same basis: price per square metre for the area you need plus your cut allowance, delivered to site. A cheap rate on a lot that loses a share of its tiles to wear, or has to be bought whole, is not cheap per square metre laid.

Condition and warranty: what to expect from each

The surplus vs reclaimed carpet tiles decision mostly comes down to condition. Surplus has no wear, and its risks are the ones storage creates: damp, crushing, mixed batches. Reclaimed has wear by definition, plus whatever the uplift did to the backing and edges. Recycled tile is new and carries neither risk.

Warranty follows the same line. A manufacturer's warranty is normally tied to the original purchaser and a compliant installation. On surplus, that usually means any remaining cover belongs to whoever bought it first. On reclaimed, the installation it was tied to has been lifted. On recycled, you are the original purchaser, so the warranty is yours on the manufacturer's terms. If a client or a lease needs a warranty in the occupier's name, that rules out the first two before price comes into it.

Whichever you are buying, check it before you pay. The inspection checklist is written for surplus, but most of it — labels, batch, backing, flatness, a counted quantity — applies to reclaimed stock as well.

Which carbon claims hold up and which don't

Claims that hold up. Surplus and reclaimed tile both mean no new tile is manufactured for the area they cover, which is a real and defensible benefit. Reclaimed also keeps tiles out of disposal at the end of a floor's life. A recycled-content tile uses less new raw material than one without, by the proportion its manufacturer states for that product.

Claims to question. Reclaimed tile is not free of impact: lifting, cleaning and transport all have one, and a claim that ignores them overstates the benefit. Recycled content is not the same as reuse, because a new tile is still being made. "Recyclable" on its own says nothing about the tile you are buying. And any figure for carbon "saved" depends on the method behind it, so a claim without one is not a figure you can repeat in a report. The fit-out guide to surplus against new covers how to agree that method on a project.

We would rather you made a modest claim you can stand behind than a large one you cannot. For surplus, the honest version is simple: these tiles already existed, and using them meant not making more.

Looking for tiles that have never been laid? See surplus carpet tiles available now, or request a quote and tell us what the floor is for.

Questions

What buyers ask about the labels.

Does Carpet Unboxed sell reclaimed tiles?

No. The marketplace lists surplus: tiles that were bought for a job and never laid. Where a listing is anything other than boxed and unused, it says so. Carpet Unboxed grew out of Welltek's carpet-tile reclaim work, which is why we are careful about the difference.

Is refurbished the same as reclaimed?

Sellers use refurbished for reclaimed tiles that have had work done before resale, such as cleaning. The word does not say what the work was, so ask what was done to the tiles and how they were checked.

Can recycled carpet tiles turn up as surplus?

Yes. A recycled-content range that was over-ordered becomes surplus like any other. The two labels answer different questions: recycled describes what the tile is made of, surplus describes what has happened to it since it was made.